Teachers’ Pay: Sixty Thousand Is a Start, Not a Solution

Gov. elect Jocelyn Benson wants Michigan teachers to start at $60,000, up from an average of $43,093. The union says every school employee needs a raise, and the funding is unanswered. Dr. Ali Bazzi goes further: $100,000 after a three year residency. Here is what the numbers say, and what it would mean for Dearborn.

The proposal on the table

Gov. elect Jocelyn Benson wants Michigan to require a starting salary of at least $60,000 a year for teachers, scaled up for experienced educators and staff in line with experience. The number is bold, and the gap it would close is real. Right now the average starting pay for a teacher in Michigan is $43,093, which ranks 45th in the nation, according to the National Education Association. Benson’s floor would sit more than $16,000 above that average. The average teacher salary in Michigan overall is $71,023, which ranks 22nd nationally, three spots lower than the year before.

The public is with her on the direction. People surveyed think teachers should start at $54,600 and average $71,445 in pay. Nearly 72 percent support increasing starting teacher salaries, and about 66.9 percent support a statewide minimum teacher salary. Benson is not alone in the call either. U.S. Senator elect Abdul El-Sayed has also called for a $60,000 minimum salary for teachers.

ADVERTISE HERE

In Article

300 by 250

75 dollars per month

Book this spot

What Benson has offered so far is a number and a promise. Her team said late Thursday that she looks forward to laying out her first 100 days agenda, including a bold education agenda. No implementation date and no legislative timeline have been stated. Her plan also includes the Michigan Education Guarantee, a statewide graduation standard so that a diploma means a graduate is college or career ready, championed by Launch Michigan, whose vice chair is Michigan Education Association president Chandra Madafferi.

A starting salary is the right place to start a debate about teaching in Michigan. It is not the whole debate. The question is whether $60,000 is enough, who else gets left out, and where the money comes from. On each of those, the record so far is thinner than the headline.

What $60,000 would change, and what it would not

Start with what the number would do. A $60,000 floor would lift every new teacher in Michigan well above the current average starting pay, and it would make teaching a more serious option for college graduates weighing debt, rent, and a first job. For a state that ranks 45th in starting pay, that is not a small thing.

But the floor would also expose how many working teachers sit below it today. As Jason Burns of the Education Policy Innovation Collaborative told Bridge Michigan, “When you consider that the average starting teacher salary in Michigan is just a hair over $43,000 right now, there are a lot of teachers who are already in classrooms, who are not brand new, who are not making $60,000.” A minimum that only lifts new hires, while experienced teachers stay below it, would be a pay plan that rewards arrival and punishes staying. Benson’s proposal says pay should scale up for experienced educators, which is the right instinct. The detail of how that scale works is where the promise will be kept or broken.

The union’s answer is that the problem is wider than starting pay. Doug Pratt, spokesperson for the Michigan Education Association, the state’s largest teachers union, said there are shortages for bus drivers and paraprofessionals too, and “it is not just a question of starting salary.” His central point deserves to stand on its own:

As a state we need to increase compensation for every school employee, not just teachers.

Pratt also pointed to rising health care costs, retirement options, class sizes, and student behaviors, and said, “It is a challenging thing to figure this out financially.” His closing line to Bridge Michigan was blunt about the stage the debate has reached: “The details matter and now we are moving past the statements of values, which we agree with, to alright, how do we implement it, how do we get this done.”

That is the honest position of a union that is not opposed to the idea but is not sold on the plan. Madafferi, the MEA president, sits on Benson’s transition team as one of 15 leaders, so the union has a seat at the table. What it does not yet have is a plan it can take to its members.

The money question nobody has answered

The largest hole in the proposal is the one Benson’s team has not addressed: cost and funding. The team did not comment on cost or on a funding source. Burns previously told Bridge Michigan it would take about $350 to $400 million to raise teacher pay in line with public opinion. That figure is a measure of the scale, not a budget, and nobody in the governor elect’s office has said where that money would come from, or whether the state would pay for it at all.

That matters because of how Michigan pays for schools today. Local districts set teacher pay, class sizes, and working conditions with local teachers unions, and districts rely on state per pupil funding. A state mandate without state money would land on districts that are already stretching that funding. Jennifer Smith of the Michigan Association of School Boards put it plainly: “If the state is saying we have to pay teachers a certain amount, then the state has to make sure the districts have the funds to do that.”

Craig Thiel of the Citizens Research Council added a warning about reading the headline number as the whole story: “Everyone might look at the bright shiny headline number, which is the salaries, but teacher compensation is broader than that.” Retirement costs are part of that broader picture. Michael Van Beek of the Mackinac Center noted that districts that raise pay must also pay more into the public retirement system, which adds a cost on top of every salary dollar.

There is a precedent for the state stepping in with money, but it is a small one. State leaders agreed to $150 million toward bonuses, with the amount per educator depending on enrollment, how many qualify, and local union negotiation. Bonuses are not a salary floor, and a one time payment is not a career.

The National Education Association adds a caution that should stay on the table through the whole debate: “Not every law raising teacher salaries is a good one. Some do not come with adequate funding to help districts, especially rural ones, meet the new bars. Others are laden with poison pills.” A mandate that districts cannot afford, or that arrives with conditions that tie their hands, would do more harm than a promise that was never made.

A superintendent who says go further

Into this debate comes a voice from Dearborn’s own backyard, and he says $60,000 is too low. Dr. Ali Y. Bazzi, president of Hamadeh Educational Services and Superintendent of Schools for all HES Academies, argues in an essay supplied to Dearborn Blog that the country should pay teachers $100,000 to start, earned after a rigorous three year residency under a veteran educator mentor, modeled on medical residencies.

His starting point reframes the whole problem. “The United States does not have a teacher shortage problem it has a compensation and investment problem.” Teaching, in his account, is treated as essential in rhetoric and optional in funding. Enrollment in teacher preparation programs is falling, early career turnover is high, and access to experienced teachers is uneven. The result is a system that leans on long term substitutes, emergency certifications, and underprepared educators, and the damage lands hardest on low income communities, where turnover is highest.

His proposal has three parts. First, the salary: $100,000 to start, after the residency. Second, the residency itself: three years under a veteran mentor, focused on instructional delivery, classroom management, and ongoing professional development, so that new teachers arrive in their own classrooms as trained professionals rather than novices thrown into the deep end. Third, the funding: the money exists but is poorly allocated. Federal and state funds are rigidly tied to programs, materials, software, and short term interventions with limited long term impact. Districts need the flexibility to direct resources to salaries and retention instead. His line for that argument is short and hard to argue with:

A curriculum does not teach students. A teacher does.

Bazzi names four effects a $100,000 starting salary would have. It would elevate the profession, so talented graduates choose teaching first rather than as a fallback, and enrollment in preparation programs rises. It would improve retention, because financial strain drives early career teachers out. It would reduce inequities, so all schools are staffed with quality educators regardless of zip code. And over the long term, college readiness would improve, academic gaps would shrink, and teaching would become a destination career rather than a stop on the way to something else.

He closes with a challenge that turns the affordability question around:

The question is not whether we can afford to do this. It is whether we can afford not to.

Bazzi’s number is far above Benson’s, and it would cost far more. But it does something Benson’s proposal has not yet done: it names the mechanism. A residency that trains teachers properly, and a funding shift that pays for the people instead of the programs around them. Whether $100,000 is the right number is a fair argument. That teaching should be paid like the profession it is, and trained like one too, is the stronger claim underneath it.

How to pay for it

Bazzi has also written about the funding side in Bridge Michigan, in a guest commentary published February 27, 2026, and his argument there is the natural companion to his pay proposal. Michigan, he writes, spends plenty on education but is not getting results overall. His words: “We spend plenty of money on education in Michigan, but overall as a state, we are not getting results.”

His answer is not to spend blindly more but to spend differently. Funding should be predictable and stable so schools can plan for student impact, and flexible because every district is different and has different needs. Outcome expectations should account for schools being overburdened with compliance rules and regulations just to qualify for the funding they need.

His specific proposal is a multiyear plan built on a per pupil weighted formula. Instead of picking winners and losers based on political favors, funding should follow students based on their needs. Students who need more support should get more support. Funding should also be steadied by letting districts use either their current student count or a three year average, whichever is higher, to determine per pupil funding. The aim is a system schools can plan around, year after year, rather than one that changes every time new people are elected.

He holds up Mississippi as proof that consistency works. Mississippi was 49th in the nation in fourth grade reading in 2013. After ten years of research based literacy training for teachers, accountability for outcomes, and standards that did not change with each election, Mississippi had improved to ninth place in fourth grade reading by 2024, and among children living in poverty it has the highest fourth grade reading scores in the country. Michigan, by contrast, ranks 44th in fourth grade reading.

The lesson for the pay debate is direct. A salary floor without a funding formula that districts can rely on is a promise written on a budget that changes every year. A weighted formula that follows need, and a count rule that protects districts when enrollment dips, would give districts the stability to hire, keep, and pay teachers properly. That is the missing piece between Benson’s number and a plan that survives contact with a school budget.

What other states did

Michigan would not be the first state to set a floor. Tennessee will require a $50,000 minimum starting salary next school year, up from $35,000. Arkansas raised its minimum from $36,000 to $50,000 in 2023, with all teachers getting at least a $2,000 raise. Researchers found the Arkansas raises significantly increased salaries in rural and high poverty districts and improved retention, though the effects fade with inflation, which means a floor that never rises is a floor that sinks in real terms.

Arkansas also carries a warning for Michigan. Its pay law also created a voucher program, the kind of add on the NEA warns about when it says some salary laws are laden with poison pills. A pay bill in Michigan will attract amendments, and what rides along with the salary floor will matter as much as the floor itself. Watch the bill, not just the headline.

The local question

There is one more argument against a state minimum that deserves a fair hearing, because it is about who decides. Today, pay is a local decision, negotiated district by district. Van Beek of the Mackinac Center, a free market think tank, said a state minimum would be “a pretty significant insertion of state policy into an area that, as long as Michigan schools have been around, has been a local decision.” He added that creating a state minimum would be “stepping into the territory that teachers unions typically have operated in.”

That is a real tension, and it is not only a conservative one. Local bargaining lets a district weigh pay against class size, support staff, and programs, and lets a union trade across those priorities. A state floor takes one of those choices off the table. The counter is that local control has produced a state that ranks 45th in starting pay, and that a floor is a minimum, not a schedule: districts can still pay more, bargain more, and decide the rest locally. The floor sets the bottom. It does not set the ceiling.

The honest version of this debate is not state against local. It is whether Michigan is willing to say that no teacher, in any district, should start below a living professional wage, and whether the state will fund the floor it sets. Both halves of that sentence have to hold, or neither does.

What it means for Dearborn

Dearborn is where this debate stops being abstract. Start with the district’s own numbers. Dearborn Public Schools’ teacher salary schedule for the 2026 to 2027 school year, effective August 19, 2026, starts a new teacher with a bachelor’s degree at $54,283, and a new teacher with a master’s degree at $58,145. Both figures sit below Benson’s proposed $60,000 floor. That means the governor elect’s proposal is not a distant statehouse argument for Dearborn. It would raise the starting pay of every new teacher in the city’s own public schools.

The academies in Dearborn Heights tell the other half of the story. Star International Academy, one of the four charter schools Hamadeh Educational Services works with, serves a largely Middle Eastern student population that includes many English language learners. Its students scored an average of 974.9 on the most recent SAT, well above the state average of 945. Nearly 94 percent of its students are economically disadvantaged. Its students have earned over $100 million in scholarships through the years, and the school is ranked the number 2 high school in all of Dearborn and Dearborn Heights by U.S. News and World Report, ahead of many far more affluent schools.

Star’s record is the point Bazzi makes in his funding commentary: the schools that work in Michigan, including schools serving Dearborn area families, do it with individual attention, rigorous standards, teachers who have room to innovate, and multiple pathways for students to succeed. Its career technical center has a working radio station where students interview state and community leaders and broadcast in English and Arabic, a robotics and engineering garage, and a working health clinic. The teachers behind those results are the same teachers the pay debate is about.

Dearborn Blog asked two local teachers for their view on what a $60,000 starting salary would mean for them and the teachers they work with, and what else besides pay needs to change for Michigan schools to keep good teachers. Neither replied by email, and a call to each went unanswered or unreturned by publication time. Their voices are missing from this article, and that is a gap we will keep open: if either of them, or any Dearborn teacher, wants to speak, we will add their words and say so plainly.

What is not missing is the stakes. A state that pays its new teachers $43,093 on average, 45th in the nation, is telling its brightest graduates that teaching is a calling to be endured rather than a career to be chosen. A city like Dearborn, whose classrooms hold the children of immigrants and working families, and whose schools already prove what those children can do, cannot afford to lose its teachers to better paying work somewhere else. Benson’s $60,000 is a start. Bazzi’s $100,000 is a challenge to think bigger. The real test is the one Pratt named: the details, the funding, and whether the state will do the work of getting it done.

Editorial Disclaimer

This article reports on Gov. elect Jocelyn Benson’s proposal for a $60,000 starting teacher salary, on the responses of the Michigan Education Association, the Michigan Association of School Boards, the Citizens Research Council, and the Mackinac Center as reported by Bridge Michigan on November 12, 2026, and on the published writings of Dr. Ali Y. Bazzi. Figures for Michigan teacher pay come from the National Education Association as cited by Bridge Michigan. Dearborn Public Schools salary figures come from the district’s own teacher salary schedule for the 2026 to 2027 school year, effective August 19, 2026. Star International Academy figures come from Dr. Bazzi’s Bridge Michigan guest commentary of February 27, 2026. The proposal has no stated cost, funding source, or implementation timeline at the time of publication. No classroom teacher is quoted by name in the Bridge Michigan article on which this report is partly based, and the two local teachers Dearborn Blog contacted did not respond before publication. This article is an independent report and analysis by Dearborn Blog and does not represent the views of any candidate, union, school district, or academy named in it.

Sources

  1. Isabel Lohman, Bridge Michigan, “Jocelyn Benson wants to raise Michigan teacher pay, union is not sold on plan,” November 12, 2026. https://bridgemi.com/michigan-education-watch/jocelyn-benson-wants-to-raise-michigan-teacher-pay-union-isnt-sold-on-plan/
  2. Ali Y. Bazzi, PhD, “What If Teaching Paid $100,000? Here is What Would Change,” supplied to Dearborn Blog, November 2026.
  3. Ali Bazzi, Bridge Michigan, “Opinion: Michigan school funding needs to be predictable and weighted,” February 27, 2026. https://bridgemi.com/guest-commentary/opinion-michigan-school-funding-needs-to-be-predictable-and-weighted/
  4. National Education Association teacher salary rankings, as cited by Bridge Michigan, November 12, 2026.
  5. Jason Burns, Education Policy Innovation Collaborative, cost estimate of $350 to $400 million, as cited by Bridge Michigan, November 12, 2026.
  6. Dearborn Public Schools, P to 12 Teacher Salary Schedule, 2026 to 2027 school year, effective August 19, 2026. https://dearbornschools.org/humanresourcesblog/wp-content/uploads/sites/63/2026/09/DFT-Updated-Salary-Schedule-2026-27.docx-1.pdf
  7. Michigan Association of School Boards, Citizens Research Council, and Mackinac Center for Public Policy, statements as cited by Bridge Michigan, November 12, 2026.
  8. U.S. News and World Report ranking of Star International Academy, as cited by Dr. Bazzi, Bridge Michigan, February 27, 2026.
  9. Tennessee and Arkansas teacher minimum salary laws, as cited by Bridge Michigan, November 12, 2026.
  10. National Education Association, statement on teacher salary laws, as cited by Bridge Michigan, November 12, 2026.

Leave a Reply